Penelope
Diamond Member
- Jul 15, 2014
- 60,265
- 15,791
- 2,210
Jews are a people. Not a race, and not a religion. Judaism is a religion, you don't have to be a Jew to practice it Jew haterI thought you were an atheist, so means your are not a jew. Jew is not a race.![]()
They have to make up their mind, in what a definition of Jew is, use to be a jew was from Judea and one who practiced Judaism, then they said had to be born of a jewish mother, and now you can become a Jew ( and in Israel you must become one to marry a jew right, and Israel wants to be called a jewish state. I think your mixed up here. As I think it said on PM Bibi Wiki article, its a tradition. You might want to listen to the you tube video by the Pres. of the Atheist Assoc of the USA, he was a jew, but he says , now he is an atheist, because see you can't be both now can you? Jew lo0ses all it meaning. Why would one avoid pork if one is an atheist, unless one is a vegetarian. I do not eat pork and I'm not a jew. Make up your mind.
Is a jew who practices Judaism in America , orthodox Judaism , an American who practices Judaism or a Jew living in America?
Penny----your post is utterly incoherent. Jews decide what jews are and are not at all confused about the issue. YOU used the term "traditional jew"-----
claiming that a poll was taken amongst "traditional jews" -------I am a jew and can describe to you how jews use the term TRADITIONAL JEW------but you would be just as confused after I described that term as you are now. . It is best not to use terms that you do not understand. Do you know what a LAPSED CATHOLIC IS? I do not try to insist to the local priest that I know and he does not
I would imagine a lapse Catholic is the same as a lapsed Jew.
I would say you are more like a lapsed human being.
Surely you are not this naive? .....Israel has never consulted the USA on its military actions and is not likely to do so in the future--------Also---the USA does not consult Israel and is not likely to do so in the future--![]()
I am not at all naïve------I am a separated officer in the US navy. The USA and Israel engage in joint training-----but have never fought in conjunction with each other. Islamic leaders have made claims that the US military joined Israel in
wars-------only to cover the reality of their defeats. Nasser was very much into this deceit in the 1967 war. He was almost comical----besides insisting that the USA was directly involved in that war------he insisted that HE WON. It gets even more stupid than that-------west Pakistan insisted that the Indian military aided east Pakistan-------sheeeesh you guys are pathetic
Are you Irosie's husband. I swear there are two of you.