Anchor baby law to be changed.

[Syriusly]

The intent of the 14th Amendment is pretty clear from the wording- it is your problem if you don't like what the 14th Amendment says

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Don't like the Constitution? Then change it.

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

The intent is clear from the language- if the writers of the 14th Amendment 'intended' it to say something other than what it says= they would - and should have written the Amendment to reflect their intention.

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.


The language of the 14th Amendment has only two requirements

• Birth within the United States and
• born subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.

Who is not born in the United States- but not subject to the United States? Then it was Indians in sovereign nations, and children of diplomats.

Now it is children of diplomats.

so now the 14million illegals are all diplomats?

Wow- you are even stupider than I had thought.

You pick your candidates by skin color and reproductive organ then call someone else stupid.

Really?

When did I do that?

 

[Syriusly]

Texas is not denying any birth certificates to illegal aliens- it is denying birth certificates to U.S. citizens.

Not exactly the intent of the 14th.
Don't think it was meant to allow the disease ridden trash from other countries to sneak across the border to plop their spawn.

The intent of the 14th Amendment is pretty clear from the wording- it is your problem if you don't like what the 14th Amendment says

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Don't like the Constitution? Then change it.

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

 

[Conservative65]

[
It'd be a lot easier to just make it harder for illegal aliens to get jobs and housing, and ramp up penalties for fining them and their employers.

Well that would be a practical and workable solution.

Nobody wants that when they can just whine about 'anchor babies'.

So sad you consider not wanting to reward someone born here as a sole result of a crime being committed as whining.

Oh those of you who wish to ignore the Constitution, and pretend that by whining about American citizens, rather than illegal immigrants are indeed just whining.

Send their fucking illegal parents packing. Bet you whine about that.

 

[Syriusly]

[
It'd be a lot easier to just make it harder for illegal aliens to get jobs and housing, and ramp up penalties for fining them and their employers.

Well that would be a practical and workable solution.

Nobody wants that when they can just whine about 'anchor babies'.

So sad you consider not wanting to reward someone born here as a sole result of a crime being committed as whining.

Actually, since the likelihood of changing birthright citizenship via either a court case or amendment is virtually zero, doing anything to make the situation more acceptable than it is would be a positive. Although I realize people like you would prefer to drown that take an objectionable flotation device.

I have an idea. Send then illegal parents back if the kid gets to stay then let the kid sink or swim on his/her own because the country doesn't owe them shit.

That is rather the Conservative ideal isn't it?

If a child is abandoned by his or her parents, let the 2 year old fend for his or herself- government shouldn't be involved?

 

[Conservative65]

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

The intent is clear from the language- if the writers of the 14th Amendment 'intended' it to say something other than what it says= they would - and should have written the Amendment to reflect their intention.

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.


The language of the 14th Amendment has only two requirements

• Birth within the United States and
• born subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.

Who is not born in the United States- but not subject to the United States? Then it was Indians in sovereign nations, and children of diplomats.

Now it is children of diplomats.

so now the 14million illegals are all diplomats?

Wow- you are even stupider than I had thought.

You pick your candidates by skin color and reproductive organ then call someone else stupid.

Really?

When did I do that?

2008 and 2012. If you vote for Hillary is she's the nominee whether you support her in the primary or not, 2016.

Don't lie bitch. At least be honest. While you'll still be a dumbass, at least you'll be one with some respect for being honest.

 

[Syriusly]

[
It'd be a lot easier to just make it harder for illegal aliens to get jobs and housing, and ramp up penalties for fining them and their employers.

Well that would be a practical and workable solution.

Nobody wants that when they can just whine about 'anchor babies'.

So sad you consider not wanting to reward someone born here as a sole result of a crime being committed as whining.

Oh those of you who wish to ignore the Constitution, and pretend that by whining about American citizens, rather than illegal immigrants are indeed just whining.

Send their fucking illegal parents packing. Bet you whine about that.

Have you seen me complain about that?

You are the one whining and complaining about the Constitution- if you don't like it- change it.

 

[Maryland Patriot]

Not exactly the intent of the 14th.
Don't think it was meant to allow the disease ridden trash from other countries to sneak across the border to plop their spawn.

The intent of the 14th Amendment is pretty clear from the wording- it is your problem if you don't like what the 14th Amendment says

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Don't like the Constitution? Then change it.

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

 

[Maryland Patriot]

[
It'd be a lot easier to just make it harder for illegal aliens to get jobs and housing, and ramp up penalties for fining them and their employers.

Well that would be a practical and workable solution.

Nobody wants that when they can just whine about 'anchor babies'.

So sad you consider not wanting to reward someone born here as a sole result of a crime being committed as whining.

Oh those of you who wish to ignore the Constitution, and pretend that by whining about American citizens, rather than illegal immigrants are indeed just whining.

Send their fucking illegal parents packing. Bet you whine about that.

Have you seen me complain about that?

You are the one whining and complaining about the Constitution- if you don't like it- change it.

no need to change it.
Just follow it as intended.

 

[Syriusly]

The intent is clear from the language- if the writers of the 14th Amendment 'intended' it to say something other than what it says= they would - and should have written the Amendment to reflect their intention.

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.


The language of the 14th Amendment has only two requirements

• Birth within the United States and
• born subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.

Who is not born in the United States- but not subject to the United States? Then it was Indians in sovereign nations, and children of diplomats.

Now it is children of diplomats.

so now the 14million illegals are all diplomats?

Wow- you are even stupider than I had thought.

You pick your candidates by skin color and reproductive organ then call someone else stupid.

Really?

When did I do that?

2008 and 2012. If you vote for Hillary is she's the nominee whether you support her in the primary or not, 2016.

Don't lie bitch. At least be honest. While you'll still be a dumbass, at least you'll be one with some respect for being honest.

You made the claim- I know you are liar but it is fun to watch you be such a blatant liar.

Now again- when did I pick any candidate by skin color or reproductive organ?

And your evidence that I did.

Who am I kidding- we all know you are just pulling this crap out of your wrinkly faux Conservative ass.

 

[Syriusly]

The intent of the 14th Amendment is pretty clear from the wording- it is your problem if you don't like what the 14th Amendment says

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Don't like the Constitution? Then change it.

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

The 14th Amendment doesn't mention slaves or Mexicans- once again the plain and simple language of the Constitution

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

 

[Syriusly]

Well that would be a practical and workable solution.

Nobody wants that when they can just whine about 'anchor babies'.

So sad you consider not wanting to reward someone born here as a sole result of a crime being committed as whining.

Oh those of you who wish to ignore the Constitution, and pretend that by whining about American citizens, rather than illegal immigrants are indeed just whining.

Send their fucking illegal parents packing. Bet you whine about that.

Have you seen me complain about that?

You are the one whining and complaining about the Constitution- if you don't like it- change it.

no need to change it.
Just follow it as intended.

You mean how you interpret it to be intended- rather than the actual language of the Constitution.

 

[froggy]

Not exactly the intent of the 14th.
Don't think it was meant to allow the disease ridden trash from other countries to sneak across the border to plop their spawn.

The intent of the 14th Amendment is pretty clear from the wording- it is your problem if you don't like what the 14th Amendment says

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Don't like the Constitution? Then change it.

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

What Is the Fourteenth Amendment and What Does It Mean?

 

[bendog]

The intent of the 14th Amendment is pretty clear from the wording- it is your problem if you don't like what the 14th Amendment says

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Don't like the Constitution? Then change it.

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

Actually, according to the companion case to Kim Ark, it does. Although they were Chinese laborers who were required to go home.

 

[Unkotare]

The intent of the 14th Amendment is pretty clear from the wording- it is your problem if you don't like what the 14th Amendment says

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

Don't like the Constitution? Then change it.

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?......

It says that anyone born here IS a citizen, filthy spawn. Learn to read, filthy spawn.

 

[Maryland Patriot]

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

The 14th Amendment doesn't mention slaves or Mexicans- once again the plain and simple language of the Constitution

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

again, were does the parent fall into all of that?
They are not legally here.

 

[froggy]

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

The 14th Amendment doesn't mention slaves or Mexicans- once again the plain and simple language of the Constitution

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

What Is the Fourteenth Amendment and What Does It Mean?

 

[bendog]

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

The 14th Amendment doesn't mention slaves or Mexicans- once again the plain and simple language of the Constitution

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

again, were does the parent fall into all of that?
They are not legally here.

Great, you want to pay for all the kids as wards of the state. Is it anyone wonder why the gop keeps losing natl elections. Give us your crazy .....

 

[Maryland Patriot]

The intent was based on the thinking of those that wrote it. You can't determine their intent based on what you think it is.

What do you do with the illegal parents of those incorrectly granted citizenship as a direct result of a crime? Do they get to stay? Does what you consider the intent of the 14th allow them to stay?

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?......

It says that anyone born here IS a citizen, filthy spawn. Learn to read, filthy spawn.

and where does the constitution allow for their parents to stay and start collecting government handouts?
I have a strong feeling that your parents are hiding in your basement from the border patrol

 

[bendog]

When the africians were freed thy were not citizens. It was so that their children would be citizens. The africians didn't sneek in here pregnant

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

The 14th Amendment doesn't mention slaves or Mexicans- once again the plain and simple language of the Constitution

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

What Is the Fourteenth Amendment and What Does It Mean?

Well that did well up to about 1877. LOL

 

[Maryland Patriot]

That was a primary intent of the 14th Amendment not to let someone born here as a result of his/her parents sneaking in and committing a crime.

Despite of course- the 14th Amendment saying no such thing.

In the same light does the 14th say that illegals can sneak in and create citizens?
I think the intent was to make the slaves citizens. don't think there was ever consideration for Mexicans sneaking in.

The 14th Amendment doesn't mention slaves or Mexicans- once again the plain and simple language of the Constitution

Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

again, were does the parent fall into all of that?
They are not legally here.

Great, you want to pay for all the kids as wards of the state. Is it anyone wonder why the gop keeps losing natl elections. Give us your crazy .....

would be cheaper than the liberal plan currently being used, pay for the whole damn illegal family to live here.
ship the parents back, they should take the spawn with them.