Stop Blaming Israel For the Gaza War

[georgephillip]

Not illegal according to INTERNATIONAL LAW and the GENEVA CONVENTIONS

The occupation was declared legal under the Geneva Conventions. No evidence of any colonialism or apartheid

The Palestinians exercise their right to self determination when they refuse to take peace and mutual borders without pre conditions

Such things happen in war, and the palestinians were the one to declare war.

Then you will be able to provide a link to their court case at the Hague on these charges

International law says that if you are attacked you can respond with military force, that is the situation the PA attack and Israel replies.

LINK

LINK


The source says it all now find a non partisan source for the same LIBELS and you will be of the hook.

Tell us what your imaginary, undocumented version of international law has to say about the legality of a state (Israel) simultaneously exercising control over a territory it occupies (Gaza) AND claiming the right to militarily attack civilians it is required to protect?

You are smart enough to understand Gaza is not a sovereign state, aren't you?

You are smart enough to realise that Israel gave up gaza in August 2005 and has not occupied the land since then. They are legally allowed to respond to attacks from hamas and other proscribed terrorist organisations.
See here for the full aspects of INTERNATIONAL LAW

http://mfa.gov.il/MFA_Graphics/MFA ..._to_Hamas_Attacks_from_Gaza_december_2008.pdf


Main Points:

Israel is in a conflict not of its own making – indeed it withdrew every
Israeli soldier and all 8000 Israeli civilians from the Gaza Strip as part of
its 2005 disengagement initiative. However, Israel has been forced to act
in defense of its citizens, who have been and continue to be deliberately
attacked by the Hamas terrorist organization.

Although Hamas makes no effort to comply with international law, Israel is
committed to limiting itself to a lawful response. This means that, while
Hamas uses civilians both as a shield and a target, Israel seeks to limit
injury to civilians on both sides.

International law recognizes that civilian deaths and injuries may occur in
lawful military operations. For an operation to be lawful it must be directed
at a "legitimate military objective" and be "proportionate".

Under the Geneva Conventions, as well as customary international law, if
a military objective, such as a missile launcher or weapons stockpile, is
placed in the heart of a civilian area, it does not cease being a lawful
military objective. The primary responsibility for civilian causalities arising
from the 'shielding' lies with the party that deliberately placed civilians at
risk.

International law also requires that any military operation be 'proportionate'
in the sense that expected collateral damage to civilians and civilian
objects must not be excessive in relation to the military advantage
anticipated. This is a complex and difficult calculation and international law
relies on the best determination of the commander in the field in the heat
of the conflict to weigh all relevant considerations, including the security of
his own forces.

Israel has adopted these principles of the law of armed conflict, in its
military training, its operational planning and in practice. Frequently,
proposed operations are cancelled because the risk of injury to civilians
might not be proportional to the military goals of the operation.

Your source is suspect

"Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs
December 2008"

Israel is in a conflict in Gaza entirely of its own making, since it was Israel that drove 200,000 Arabs from their farms, homes, and businesses in 1948 and into teeming refugee camps in Gaza.

Israel withdrew 8000 squatters and 20,000 troops from Gaza in 2005 while maintaining effective control of the civilian population by controlling most land borders, all of Gaza's airspace and coastal waters, Gaza's electromagnetic sphere and population registry.

Your IDF tripe about its commitment to international law is belied by its use of artillery in densely packed urban neighborhood, One 40kg artillery shell is designed to kill everyone within a 50 meter radius and wound everyone up to 100 meters.

Israel has used thousands of such shell to level entire city blocks in Gaza.

Jews do this because they want all the land of Palestine for themselves.

Apparently you're too stupid (or Jewish) to see that

http://mfa.gov.il/MFA_Graphics/MFA%20Gallery/Documents/Responding_to_Hamas_Attacks_from_Gaza_december_2008.pdf

 

[Sally]

Tell us what your imaginary, undocumented version of international law has to say about the legality of a state (Israel) simultaneously exercising control over a territory it occupies (Gaza) AND claiming the right to militarily attack civilians it is required to protect?

You are smart enough to understand Gaza is not a sovereign state, aren't you?

You are smart enough to realise that Israel gave up gaza in August 2005 and has not occupied the land since then. They are legally allowed to respond to attacks from hamas and other proscribed terrorist organisations.
See here for the full aspects of INTERNATIONAL LAW

http://mfa.gov.il/MFA_Graphics/MFA ..._to_Hamas_Attacks_from_Gaza_december_2008.pdf


Main Points:

Israel is in a conflict not of its own making – indeed it withdrew every
Israeli soldier and all 8000 Israeli civilians from the Gaza Strip as part of
its 2005 disengagement initiative. However, Israel has been forced to act
in defense of its citizens, who have been and continue to be deliberately
attacked by the Hamas terrorist organization.

Although Hamas makes no effort to comply with international law, Israel is
committed to limiting itself to a lawful response. This means that, while
Hamas uses civilians both as a shield and a target, Israel seeks to limit
injury to civilians on both sides.

International law recognizes that civilian deaths and injuries may occur in
lawful military operations. For an operation to be lawful it must be directed
at a "legitimate military objective" and be "proportionate".

Under the Geneva Conventions, as well as customary international law, if
a military objective, such as a missile launcher or weapons stockpile, is
placed in the heart of a civilian area, it does not cease being a lawful
military objective. The primary responsibility for civilian causalities arising
from the 'shielding' lies with the party that deliberately placed civilians at
risk.

International law also requires that any military operation be 'proportionate'
in the sense that expected collateral damage to civilians and civilian
objects must not be excessive in relation to the military advantage
anticipated. This is a complex and difficult calculation and international law
relies on the best determination of the commander in the field in the heat
of the conflict to weigh all relevant considerations, including the security of
his own forces.

Israel has adopted these principles of the law of armed conflict, in its
military training, its operational planning and in practice. Frequently,
proposed operations are cancelled because the risk of injury to civilians
might not be proportional to the military goals of the operation.

Your source is suspect

"Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs
December 2008"

Israel is in a conflict in Gaza entirely of its own making, since it was Israel that drove 200,000 Arabs from their farms, homes, and businesses in 1948 and into teeming refugee camps in Gaza.

Israel withdrew 8000 squatters and 20,000 troops from Gaza in 2005 while maintaining effective control of the civilian population by controlling most land borders, all of Gaza's airspace and coastal waters, Gaza's electromagnetic sphere and population registry.

Your IDF tripe about its commitment to international law is belied by its use of artillery in densely packed urban neighborhood, One 40kg artillery shell is designed to kill everyone within a 50 meter radius and wound everyone up to 100 meters.

Israel has used thousands of such shell to level entire city blocks in Gaza.

Jews do this because they want all the land of Palestine for themselves.

Apparently you're too stupid (or Jewish) to see that

http://mfa.gov.il/MFA_Graphics/MFA%20Gallery/Documents/Responding_to_Hamas_Attacks_from_Gaza_december_2008.pdf

I wonder if Gaza George can get over his obsession with his favorite scapegoats, the Jews, for the moment, and since he is on a Middle East forum, can give us his opinion as to why many of his new masters want a worldwide Caliphate that they are willing to kill anyone who is in their way from achieving this. Don't these Muslims think that they are governing enough countries in the Middle East, Africa and Southeast Asia? Do they really have to rule the entire world under Islam?

 

[georgephillip]

There is no "occupation". There is only Islamic jihad being waged by uncivilized, barbaric, savage idiots known as Hamas.

The UN, US, assorted human rights organizations along with most states agree Israel illegally occupies the West Bank by virtue of its filling the West Bank with hundreds of thousands of illegal squatters.

Gaza is also occupied by Israel's control of Gazan airspace, coastal waters, electromagnetic sphere, and population registry.

Jews have proven by their actions over the past 66 years they want all the land between the River and the sea for Jews alone, or with the absolute minimum of non-Jews living there as possible.

Occupation is how Jews intend to make that happen.

Have you heard of the "RIGHT OF RETURN" that applies to the 1 million Jews forcibly evicted from their homes and property between may 1948 and 1951. Then we have the Oslo accords that the P.A. tried to use a few months ago when it threatened to dissolve the P.A. making Israel fully responsible for the west bank.

Gaza is under blockade because of acts of war by hamas and the use of illegal chemical/biological weapons aimed at Israeli children. Hamas has the power to lift the blockade by giving up all violence, terrorism and belligerence and agreeing to talks on peace and mutually agreed borders.


Jews have given up land for peace thus making your claims null and void, just look at the terms of the peace treaty with Egypt and Jordan were Israel gives up large areas of occupied land and some parts of Israel in this fabled land between the river and the sea.

Jews gave up the Sinai after nearly losing it militarily in 1973, and that was after Egypt offered the same deal in 1971. Why don't you link to any land swaps between the River and the sea, and also to those allegations of chemical and biological weapons aimed at Israeli children?

Gaza is under blockade today because Jews drove two hundred thousand Arabs off their land in 1948 and into refugee camps in Gaza. The RIGHT OF RETURN applies to Jews world wide, but not to 700,000 Arabs who lost their homes, businesses, farms, and bank accounts to Jews in 1948.

Israel has no legal or moral right to exist as a Jewish state on lands stolen from non-Jews, in spite of what your rabbi tells you.

 

[Sally]

The UN, US, assorted human rights organizations along with most states agree Israel illegally occupies the West Bank by virtue of its filling the West Bank with hundreds of thousands of illegal squatters.

Gaza is also occupied by Israel's control of Gazan airspace, coastal waters, electromagnetic sphere, and population registry.

Jews have proven by their actions over the past 66 years they want all the land between the River and the sea for Jews alone, or with the absolute minimum of non-Jews living there as possible.

Occupation is how Jews intend to make that happen.

Have you heard of the "RIGHT OF RETURN" that applies to the 1 million Jews forcibly evicted from their homes and property between may 1948 and 1951. Then we have the Oslo accords that the P.A. tried to use a few months ago when it threatened to dissolve the P.A. making Israel fully responsible for the west bank.

Gaza is under blockade because of acts of war by hamas and the use of illegal chemical/biological weapons aimed at Israeli children. Hamas has the power to lift the blockade by giving up all violence, terrorism and belligerence and agreeing to talks on peace and mutually agreed borders.


Jews have given up land for peace thus making your claims null and void, just look at the terms of the peace treaty with Egypt and Jordan were Israel gives up large areas of occupied land and some parts of Israel in this fabled land between the river and the sea.

Jews gave up the Sinai after nearly losing it militarily in 1973, and that was after Egypt offered the same deal in 1971. Why don't you link to any land swaps between the River and the sea, and also to those allegations of chemical and biological weapons aimed at Israeli children?

Gaza is under blockade today because Jews drove two hundred thousand Arabs off their land in 1948 and into refugee camps in Gaza. The RIGHT OF RETURN applies to Jews world wide, but not to 700,000 Arabs who lost their homes, businesses, farms, and bank accounts to Jews in 1948.

Israel has no legal or moral right to exist as a Jewish state on lands stolen from non-Jews, in spite of what your rabbi tells you.

It is really amusing to see Gaza George ranting and raving about the "Palestinians" as if he really cared about them. If his favorite scapegoats, the Jews, weren't involved, he wouldn't care about them at all. Has anyone seen him ever post about the unfortunate Arabs who are being murdered by their fellow Arabs in the rest of the Middle East. Tens and tens of thouands of them have been murdered by their fellow Arabs in just the last three years, and not a word from Gaza George condemning this. If Gaza George can't drag in the Jews, he just isn't interested in these Arabs at all no matter how many have been murdered and no matter how many of them are still suffering. One would think that since he is posting on a Middle East forum that he could fake it a little bit to try to make the viewers believe that he actually cares about the Arabs. However, it appears that he doesn't want to even be bothered doing that.

 

[Slyhunter]

The UN, US, assorted human rights organizations along with most states agree Israel illegally occupies the West Bank by virtue of its filling the West Bank with hundreds of thousands of illegal squatters.

Gaza is also occupied by Israel's control of Gazan airspace, coastal waters, electromagnetic sphere, and population registry.

Jews have proven by their actions over the past 66 years they want all the land between the River and the sea for Jews alone, or with the absolute minimum of non-Jews living there as possible.

Occupation is how Jews intend to make that happen.

Have you heard of the "RIGHT OF RETURN" that applies to the 1 million Jews forcibly evicted from their homes and property between may 1948 and 1951. Then we have the Oslo accords that the P.A. tried to use a few months ago when it threatened to dissolve the P.A. making Israel fully responsible for the west bank.

Gaza is under blockade because of acts of war by hamas and the use of illegal chemical/biological weapons aimed at Israeli children. Hamas has the power to lift the blockade by giving up all violence, terrorism and belligerence and agreeing to talks on peace and mutually agreed borders.


Jews have given up land for peace thus making your claims null and void, just look at the terms of the peace treaty with Egypt and Jordan were Israel gives up large areas of occupied land and some parts of Israel in this fabled land between the river and the sea.

Jews gave up the Sinai after nearly losing it militarily in 1973, and that was after Egypt offered the same deal in 1971. Why don't you link to any land swaps between the River and the sea, and also to those allegations of chemical and biological weapons aimed at Israeli children?

Gaza is under blockade today because Jews drove two hundred thousand Arabs off their land in 1948 and into refugee camps in Gaza. The RIGHT OF RETURN applies to Jews world wide, but not to 700,000 Arabs who lost their homes, businesses, farms, and bank accounts to Jews in 1948.

Israel has no legal or moral right to exist as a Jewish state on lands stolen from non-Jews, in spite of what your rabbi tells you.

Get over it. Israel belongs to the Jews even if they have to kill every Gazan to keep it. You want to live learn to live with Israel in peace.

 

[Slyhunter]

Have you heard of the "RIGHT OF RETURN" that applies to the 1 million Jews forcibly evicted from their homes and property between may 1948 and 1951. Then we have the Oslo accords that the P.A. tried to use a few months ago when it threatened to dissolve the P.A. making Israel fully responsible for the west bank.

Gaza is under blockade because of acts of war by hamas and the use of illegal chemical/biological weapons aimed at Israeli children. Hamas has the power to lift the blockade by giving up all violence, terrorism and belligerence and agreeing to talks on peace and mutually agreed borders.


Jews have given up land for peace thus making your claims null and void, just look at the terms of the peace treaty with Egypt and Jordan were Israel gives up large areas of occupied land and some parts of Israel in this fabled land between the river and the sea.

Jews gave up the Sinai after nearly losing it militarily in 1973, and that was after Egypt offered the same deal in 1971. Why don't you link to any land swaps between the River and the sea, and also to those allegations of chemical and biological weapons aimed at Israeli children?

Gaza is under blockade today because Jews drove two hundred thousand Arabs off their land in 1948 and into refugee camps in Gaza. The RIGHT OF RETURN applies to Jews world wide, but not to 700,000 Arabs who lost their homes, businesses, farms, and bank accounts to Jews in 1948.

Israel has no legal or moral right to exist as a Jewish state on lands stolen from non-Jews, in spite of what your rabbi tells you.

It is really amusing to see Gaza George ranting and raving about the "Palestinians" as if he really cared about them. If his favorite scapegoats, the Jews, weren't involved, he wouldn't care about them at all. Has anyone seen him ever post about the unfortunate Arabs who are being murdered by their fellow Arabs in the rest of the Middle East. Tens and tens of thouands of them have been murdered by their fellow Arabs in just the last three years, and not a word from Gaza George condemning this. If Gaza George can't drag in the Jews, he just isn't interested in these Arabs at all no matter how many have been murdered and no matter how many of them are still suffering. One would think that since he is posting on a Middle East forum that he could fake it a little bit to try to make the viewers believe that he actually cares about the Arabs. However, it appears that he doesn't want to even be bothered doing that.

Does George have you on ignore because he's completely ignoring all of your posts.

 

[Sally]

Jews gave up the Sinai after nearly losing it militarily in 1973, and that was after Egypt offered the same deal in 1971. Why don't you link to any land swaps between the River and the sea, and also to those allegations of chemical and biological weapons aimed at Israeli children?

Gaza is under blockade today because Jews drove two hundred thousand Arabs off their land in 1948 and into refugee camps in Gaza. The RIGHT OF RETURN applies to Jews world wide, but not to 700,000 Arabs who lost their homes, businesses, farms, and bank accounts to Jews in 1948.

Israel has no legal or moral right to exist as a Jewish state on lands stolen from non-Jews, in spite of what your rabbi tells you.

It is really amusing to see Gaza George ranting and raving about the "Palestinians" as if he really cared about them. If his favorite scapegoats, the Jews, weren't involved, he wouldn't care about them at all. Has anyone seen him ever post about the unfortunate Arabs who are being murdered by their fellow Arabs in the rest of the Middle East. Tens and tens of thouands of them have been murdered by their fellow Arabs in just the last three years, and not a word from Gaza George condemning this. If Gaza George can't drag in the Jews, he just isn't interested in these Arabs at all no matter how many have been murdered and no matter how many of them are still suffering. One would think that since he is posting on a Middle East forum that he could fake it a little bit to try to make the viewers believe that he actually cares about the Arabs. However, it appears that he doesn't want to even be bothered doing that.

Does George have you on ignore because he's completely ignoring all of your posts.

Who knows? Perhaps he has no answer for why he is on a Middle East forum and completely ignores the news about what is happening to innocent Arabs because he is too obsessed with the Jews. You know how losers always need a scapegoat to blame for their own failures in life, so the Jews have been picked by Gaza George as his favorite scapegoats. Meanwhile, as the rest of us know, the Arabs, both Christians and Muslims, are suffering greatly in the other Middle East countries, and it looks like it will not end soon.

 

[Penelope]

It is really amusing to see Gaza George ranting and raving about the "Palestinians" as if he really cared about them. If his favorite scapegoats, the Jews, weren't involved, he wouldn't care about them at all. Has anyone seen him ever post about the unfortunate Arabs who are being murdered by their fellow Arabs in the rest of the Middle East. Tens and tens of thouands of them have been murdered by their fellow Arabs in just the last three years, and not a word from Gaza George condemning this. If Gaza George can't drag in the Jews, he just isn't interested in these Arabs at all no matter how many have been murdered and no matter how many of them are still suffering. One would think that since he is posting on a Middle East forum that he could fake it a little bit to try to make the viewers believe that he actually cares about the Arabs. However, it appears that he doesn't want to even be bothered doing that.

Does George have you on ignore because he's completely ignoring all of your posts.

Who knows? Perhaps he has no answer for why he is on a Middle East forum and completely ignores the news about what is happening to innocent Arabs because he is too obsessed with the Jews. You know how losers always need a scapegoat to blame for their own failures in life, so the Jews have been picked by Gaza George as his favorite scapegoats. Meanwhile, as the rest of us know, the Arabs, both Christians and Muslims, are suffering greatly in the other Middle East countries, and it looks like it will not end soon.

Jews use scapegoats. Haven't you read your OT? Now they call them false flags.

 

[Sally]

Does George have you on ignore because he's completely ignoring all of your posts.

Who knows? Perhaps he has no answer for why he is on a Middle East forum and completely ignores the news about what is happening to innocent Arabs because he is too obsessed with the Jews. You know how losers always need a scapegoat to blame for their own failures in life, so the Jews have been picked by Gaza George as his favorite scapegoats. Meanwhile, as the rest of us know, the Arabs, both Christians and Muslims, are suffering greatly in the other Middle East countries, and it looks like it will not end soon.

Jews use scapegoats. Haven't you read your OT? Now they call them false flags.

What would the NeoNazis/Islamofascists like Penelope do if they didn't have the hate sites to go for their information? So tell us, Penelope, are you also going to get over your obsession with the Jews on a Middle East forum and report to us what is going on in one Middle East country? How about Saudi Arabia? Anything new going on there? How about the Emirates? Something must be happening there? Surely you don't go to bed at night with a special mantra that you repeat to yourself over and over that you must get on forums and vomit out about the Jews.

 

[georgephillip]

You are smart enough to realise that Israel gave up gaza in August 2005 and has not occupied the land since then. They are legally allowed to respond to attacks from hamas and other proscribed terrorist organisations.
See here for the full aspects of INTERNATIONAL LAW

http://mfa.gov.il/MFA_Graphics/MFA ..._to_Hamas_Attacks_from_Gaza_december_2008.pdf


Main Points:

Israel is in a conflict not of its own making – indeed it withdrew every
Israeli soldier and all 8000 Israeli civilians from the Gaza Strip as part of
its 2005 disengagement initiative. However, Israel has been forced to act
in defense of its citizens, who have been and continue to be deliberately
attacked by the Hamas terrorist organization.

Although Hamas makes no effort to comply with international law, Israel is
committed to limiting itself to a lawful response. This means that, while
Hamas uses civilians both as a shield and a target, Israel seeks to limit
injury to civilians on both sides.

International law recognizes that civilian deaths and injuries may occur in
lawful military operations. For an operation to be lawful it must be directed
at a "legitimate military objective" and be "proportionate".

Under the Geneva Conventions, as well as customary international law, if
a military objective, such as a missile launcher or weapons stockpile, is
placed in the heart of a civilian area, it does not cease being a lawful
military objective. The primary responsibility for civilian causalities arising
from the 'shielding' lies with the party that deliberately placed civilians at
risk.

International law also requires that any military operation be 'proportionate'
in the sense that expected collateral damage to civilians and civilian
objects must not be excessive in relation to the military advantage
anticipated. This is a complex and difficult calculation and international law
relies on the best determination of the commander in the field in the heat
of the conflict to weigh all relevant considerations, including the security of
his own forces.

Israel has adopted these principles of the law of armed conflict, in its
military training, its operational planning and in practice. Frequently,
proposed operations are cancelled because the risk of injury to civilians
might not be proportional to the military goals of the operation.

Your source is suspect

"Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs
December 2008"

Israel is in a conflict in Gaza entirely of its own making, since it was Israel that drove 200,000 Arabs from their farms, homes, and businesses in 1948 and into teeming refugee camps in Gaza.

Israel withdrew 8000 squatters and 20,000 troops from Gaza in 2005 while maintaining effective control of the civilian population by controlling most land borders, all of Gaza's airspace and coastal waters, Gaza's electromagnetic sphere and population registry.

Your IDF tripe about its commitment to international law is belied by its use of artillery in densely packed urban neighborhood, One 40kg artillery shell is designed to kill everyone within a 50 meter radius and wound everyone up to 100 meters.

Israel has used thousands of such shell to level entire city blocks in Gaza.

Jews do this because they want all the land of Palestine for themselves.

Apparently you're too stupid (or Jewish) to see that

http://mfa.gov.il/MFA_Graphics/MFA%20Gallery/Documents/Responding_to_Hamas_Attacks_from_Gaza_december_2008.pdf

I wonder if Gaza George can get over his obsession with his favorite scapegoats, the Jews, for the moment, and since he is on a Middle East forum, can give us his opinion as to why many of his new masters want a worldwide Caliphate that they are willing to kill anyone who is in their way from achieving this. Don't these Muslims think that they are governing enough countries in the Middle East, Africa and Southeast Asia? Do they really have to rule the entire world under Islam?

Why are you ashamed to be Jewish?
Does it help to shed crocodile tears over innocent humans murdered by Arabs instead of Jews?
You're a one-trick pony with zero credibility and conscience.

 

[The Rabbi]

Does George have you on ignore because he's completely ignoring all of your posts.

Who knows? Perhaps he has no answer for why he is on a Middle East forum and completely ignores the news about what is happening to innocent Arabs because he is too obsessed with the Jews. You know how losers always need a scapegoat to blame for their own failures in life, so the Jews have been picked by Gaza George as his favorite scapegoats. Meanwhile, as the rest of us know, the Arabs, both Christians and Muslims, are suffering greatly in the other Middle East countries, and it looks like it will not end soon.

Jews use scapegoats. Haven't you read your OT? Now they call them false flags.

Add two things to the long list you know nothing about.

 

[georgephillip]

Have you heard of the "RIGHT OF RETURN" that applies to the 1 million Jews forcibly evicted from their homes and property between may 1948 and 1951. Then we have the Oslo accords that the P.A. tried to use a few months ago when it threatened to dissolve the P.A. making Israel fully responsible for the west bank.

Gaza is under blockade because of acts of war by hamas and the use of illegal chemical/biological weapons aimed at Israeli children. Hamas has the power to lift the blockade by giving up all violence, terrorism and belligerence and agreeing to talks on peace and mutually agreed borders.


Jews have given up land for peace thus making your claims null and void, just look at the terms of the peace treaty with Egypt and Jordan were Israel gives up large areas of occupied land and some parts of Israel in this fabled land between the river and the sea.

Jews gave up the Sinai after nearly losing it militarily in 1973, and that was after Egypt offered the same deal in 1971. Why don't you link to any land swaps between the River and the sea, and also to those allegations of chemical and biological weapons aimed at Israeli children?

Gaza is under blockade today because Jews drove two hundred thousand Arabs off their land in 1948 and into refugee camps in Gaza. The RIGHT OF RETURN applies to Jews world wide, but not to 700,000 Arabs who lost their homes, businesses, farms, and bank accounts to Jews in 1948.

Israel has no legal or moral right to exist as a Jewish state on lands stolen from non-Jews, in spite of what your rabbi tells you.

Get over it. Israel belongs to the Jews even if they have to kill every Gazan to keep it. You want to live learn to live with Israel in peace.

Gaza isn't part of Israel.
It's occupied by Israel.
Do you understand the difference?

 

[Sally]

Jews gave up the Sinai after nearly losing it militarily in 1973, and that was after Egypt offered the same deal in 1971. Why don't you link to any land swaps between the River and the sea, and also to those allegations of chemical and biological weapons aimed at Israeli children?

Gaza is under blockade today because Jews drove two hundred thousand Arabs off their land in 1948 and into refugee camps in Gaza. The RIGHT OF RETURN applies to Jews world wide, but not to 700,000 Arabs who lost their homes, businesses, farms, and bank accounts to Jews in 1948.

Israel has no legal or moral right to exist as a Jewish state on lands stolen from non-Jews, in spite of what your rabbi tells you.

Get over it. Israel belongs to the Jews even if they have to kill every Gazan to keep it. You want to live learn to live with Israel in peace.

Gaza isn't part of Israel.
It's occupied by Israel.
Do you understand the difference?

Evidently you didn't sit up and listen when Hamas said that Gaza wasn't occupied. Meanwhile, Gaza George would have loved to see rocket after rocket shot into Israel and his scapegoats, the Jews, should have just laid down and taken it without retaliating. Meanwhile, Gaza George, have you anything to report to us about what is going on in the rest of the Middle East?

 

[georgephillip]

Get over it. Israel belongs to the Jews even if they have to kill every Gazan to keep it. You want to live learn to live with Israel in peace.

Gaza isn't part of Israel.
It's occupied by Israel.
Do you understand the difference?

Evidently you didn't sit up and listen when Hamas said that Gaza wasn't occupied. Meanwhile, Gaza George would have loved to see rocket after rocket shot into Israel and his scapegoats, the Jews, should have just laid down and taken it without retaliating. Meanwhile, Gaza George, have you anything to report to us about what is going on in the rest of the Middle East?

Maybe your heroic Jews should stop murdering children on peaceful Gazan beaches. Remember that one, Hasbara Sal? Two shells fired thirty seconds apart killed four cousins in front of a hotel filled with international journalists? Why do your people do things like that, and then act surprised when much of the world spits on them for their racist, inhuman actions? Surely, you would never do such a thing, would you?

 

[Sally]

Gaza isn't part of Israel.
It's occupied by Israel.
Do you understand the difference?

Evidently you didn't sit up and listen when Hamas said that Gaza wasn't occupied. Meanwhile, Gaza George would have loved to see rocket after rocket shot into Israel and his scapegoats, the Jews, should have just laid down and taken it without retaliating. Meanwhile, Gaza George, have you anything to report to us about what is going on in the rest of the Middle East?

Maybe your heroic Jews should stop murdering children on peaceful Gazan beaches. Remember that one, Hasbara Sal? Two shells fired thirty seconds apart killed four cousins in front of a hotel filled with international journalists? Why do your people do things like that, and then act surprised when much of the world spits on them for their racist, inhuman actions? Surely, you would never do such a thing, would you?

Gaza George, you still think you are fooling people that you actually care about Arabs??? If you cared, you would have been posting all along and condemning what is happening to them in other Middle East countries where tens and tens of thousands of them have been murdered. I think that the viewers realize by now what a loser you are, and how you are desperately in need of a scapegoat for your own failures in life. Perhaps in time you can bestir yourself and actually give us some news on this Middle East forum which doesn't concern your favorite scapegoats.

 

[aris2chat]

Hamas wants the sea and ski, but in March a private boat was stopped trying to bring rockets from Iran. If they have a long floating pier or dig a deep water port it becomes a threat to Israel by making it easier for hamas to rearm. Even if ships have to stop in cyprus for inspections before heading to gaza, the supply of banned items will mean hamas can fire with a range where 75% of the Israeli population and manufacturing is located.

 

[georgephillip]

Hamas wants the sea and ski, but in March a private boat was stopped trying to bring rockets from Iran. If they have a long floating pier or dig a deep water port it becomes a threat to Israel by making it easier for hamas to rearm. Even if ships have to stop in cyprus for inspections before heading to gaza, the supply of banned items will mean hamas can fire with a range where 75% of the Israeli population and manufacturing is located.

In which case, Jews in Israel will have to abandon the Zionist dream of controlling all of Palestine for Jews alone, won't they?

 

[aris2chat]

Gaza isn't part of Israel.
It's occupied by Israel.
Do you understand the difference?

Evidently you didn't sit up and listen when Hamas said that Gaza wasn't occupied. Meanwhile, Gaza George would have loved to see rocket after rocket shot into Israel and his scapegoats, the Jews, should have just laid down and taken it without retaliating. Meanwhile, Gaza George, have you anything to report to us about what is going on in the rest of the Middle East?

Maybe your heroic Jews should stop murdering children on peaceful Gazan beaches. Remember that one, Hasbara Sal? Two shells fired thirty seconds apart killed four cousins in front of a hotel filled with international journalists? Why do your people do things like that, and then act surprised when much of the world spits on them for their racist, inhuman actions? Surely, you would never do such a thing, would you?

Gaza has not been peaceful since Israel withdrew. Trying to get a shipment of Iranians rockets just a couple of months ago shows they had no intention of being peaceful.

 

[georgephillip]

Evidently you didn't sit up and listen when Hamas said that Gaza wasn't occupied. Meanwhile, Gaza George would have loved to see rocket after rocket shot into Israel and his scapegoats, the Jews, should have just laid down and taken it without retaliating. Meanwhile, Gaza George, have you anything to report to us about what is going on in the rest of the Middle East?

Maybe your heroic Jews should stop murdering children on peaceful Gazan beaches. Remember that one, Hasbara Sal? Two shells fired thirty seconds apart killed four cousins in front of a hotel filled with international journalists? Why do your people do things like that, and then act surprised when much of the world spits on them for their racist, inhuman actions? Surely, you would never do such a thing, would you?

Gaza has not been peaceful since Israel withdrew. Trying to get a shipment of Iranians rockets just a couple of months ago shows they had no intention of being peaceful.

Israel has never left Gaza; today it controls the airspace, coastal waters, and most land borders of Gaza. Israel defines how many daily calories each resident of Gaza receives. Nothing Gaza produces is allowed to be exported. Jews have held the view for a hundred years they are entitled to rule all Palestine for their benefit alone. If they don't disabuse themselves of that delusion, they are going to suffer another historical failure, and this time, it will be a failure they richly deserve.

 

[Indeependent]

Why does anybody respond to George?
He makes mindless robots seem interesting.