Who Are The Palestinians? Part 2

[JoelT1]

We don't disagree. Normally, when a territory transfers from one sovereign to another (in this case from the Ottoman Empire to the Jewish homeland) ALL of the citizens transfer with that territory, along with its boundaries. We agree.

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Jews were originally

You obviously didn't read the post I was responding to. You know. Where that is contested.

And this whole conflict can be resolved easily and quickly if the Arab half of the Palestinian people -- both Arabs and Jews -- would realize that it's NOT Arab stuff.

When did I mention Arabs?

Tin brain does not think that Palestinians are Arabs.

Here is a pro Palestinian article which may just clear things for him:

The Arabs of Palestine

OK, so most are.

What is the relevance?

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language

We don't disagree. Normally, when a territory transfers from one sovereign to another (in this case from the Ottoman Empire to the Jewish homeland) ALL of the citizens transfer with that territory, along with its boundaries. We agree.

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Oh jeese, more Israeli talking points.

Princeton Univ. Professor Bernard Lewis, Dean of Middle East historians: Romans rename Jews’ land palestine

 

[P F Tinmore]

Nadia Hijab | Shaping a Different US Policy Toward Palestinians: What Would It Take?

 

[Coyote]

You obviously didn't read the post I was responding to. You know. Where that is contested.

And this whole conflict can be resolved easily and quickly if the Arab half of the Palestinian people -- both Arabs and Jews -- would realize that it's NOT Arab stuff.

When did I mention Arabs?

Tin brain does not think that Palestinians are Arabs.

Here is a pro Palestinian article which may just clear things for him:

The Arabs of Palestine

OK, so most are.

What is the relevance?

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language

We don't disagree. Normally, when a territory transfers from one sovereign to another (in this case from the Ottoman Empire to the Jewish homeland) ALL of the citizens transfer with that territory, along with its boundaries. We agree.

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Oh jeese, more Israeli talking points.

Yes ... indeed...

 

[Coyote]

You keep banging on about an issue that is not contested.

But, do they have the right to kill people, destroy and steal their stuff.

Of course not.

You obviously didn't read the post I was responding to. You know. Where that is contested.

And this whole conflict can be resolved easily and quickly if the Arab half of the Palestinian people -- both Arabs and Jews -- would realize that it's NOT Arab stuff.

When did I mention Arabs?

Tin brain does not think that Palestinians are Arabs.

Here is a pro Palestinian article which may just clear things for him:

The Arabs of Palestine

OK, so most are.

What is the relevance?

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language

We don't disagree. Normally, when a territory transfers from one sovereign to another (in this case from the Ottoman Empire to the Jewish homeland) ALL of the citizens transfer with that territory, along with its boundaries. We agree.

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Why do you hate Palestinians?

 

[JoelT1]

You obviously didn't read the post I was responding to. You know. Where that is contested.

And this whole conflict can be resolved easily and quickly if the Arab half of the Palestinian people -- both Arabs and Jews -- would realize that it's NOT Arab stuff.

When did I mention Arabs?

Tin brain does not think that Palestinians are Arabs.

Here is a pro Palestinian article which may just clear things for him:

The Arabs of Palestine

OK, so most are.

What is the relevance?

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language

We don't disagree. Normally, when a territory transfers from one sovereign to another (in this case from the Ottoman Empire to the Jewish homeland) ALL of the citizens transfer with that territory, along with its boundaries. We agree.

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Why do you hate Palestinians?

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British. Made-up word

 

[Coyote]

When did I mention Arabs?

Tin brain does not think that Palestinians are Arabs.

Here is a pro Palestinian article which may just clear things for him:

The Arabs of Palestine

OK, so most are.

What is the relevance?

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language

We don't disagree. Normally, when a territory transfers from one sovereign to another (in this case from the Ottoman Empire to the Jewish homeland) ALL of the citizens transfer with that territory, along with its boundaries. We agree.

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Why do you hate Palestinians?

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British. Made-up word

No. Not made up.

A descriptor of very real people that live there. Real people. Just like the Jews are. Your persistent effort to diminish and demean them is not unlike that of the antisemites who do the same to the Jews.

 

[JoelT1]

Tin brain does not think that Palestinians are Arabs.

Here is a pro Palestinian article which may just clear things for him:

The Arabs of Palestine

OK, so most are.

What is the relevance?

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language

We don't disagree. Normally, when a territory transfers from one sovereign to another (in this case from the Ottoman Empire to the Jewish homeland) ALL of the citizens transfer with that territory, along with its boundaries. We agree.

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Why do you hate Palestinians?

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British. Made-up word

No. Not made up.

A descriptor of very real people that live there. Real people. Just like the Jews are. Your persistent effort to diminish and demean them is not unlike that of the antisemites who do the same to the Jews.

The British coined the word “palestinian” originally for Jews in the British Mandate temporarily named British palestine. Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews and ancient Israel.

 

[Coyote]

OK, so most are.

What is the relevance?

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language

The territory was ceded to Palestine and the Palestinians got Palestinian citizenship.

Can you refute that?

History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Why do you hate Palestinians?

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British. Made-up word

No. Not made up.

A descriptor of very real people that live there. Real people. Just like the Jews are. Your persistent effort to diminish and demean them is not unlike that of the antisemites who do the same to the Jews.

The British coined the word “palestinian” originally for Jews in the British Mandate temporarily named British palestine. Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews and ancient Israel.

Coined or not, Palestinians are a people in today's world. Why is it so important to diminish them?

 

[JoelT1]

You were clueless that “palestinians” are Arabs? Their native Arabic language
History Lesson: Palestine, Roman name for Jews’ land of Israel

Why do you hate Palestinians?

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British. Made-up word

No. Not made up.

A descriptor of very real people that live there. Real people. Just like the Jews are. Your persistent effort to diminish and demean them is not unlike that of the antisemites who do the same to the Jews.

The British coined the word “palestinian” originally for Jews in the British Mandate temporarily named British palestine. Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews and ancient Israel.

Coined or not, Palestinians are a people in today's world. Why is it so important to diminish them?

“Palestinian” coined by the British for Jews. There’s no p in Arabic

 

[Shusha]

The British coined the word “palestinian” originally for Jews in the British Mandate temporarily named British palestine. Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews and ancient Israel.

It doesn't matter one tiny bit where the name came from. Coyote is right. The Arab Palestinians, regardless of their origins, exist now. They are a real people and they have every right to be there. Same as the Jewish people.

We can't support the rights of one people, while denying the rights of the other. THAT works both ways.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Jennifer Jajeh

 

[Coyote]

Why do you hate Palestinians?

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British. Made-up word

No. Not made up.

A descriptor of very real people that live there. Real people. Just like the Jews are. Your persistent effort to diminish and demean them is not unlike that of the antisemites who do the same to the Jews.

The British coined the word “palestinian” originally for Jews in the British Mandate temporarily named British palestine. Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews and ancient Israel.

Coined or not, Palestinians are a people in today's world. Why is it so important to diminish them?

“Palestinian” coined by the British for Jews. There’s no p in Arabic

Why do you feel the need to diminish Palestinians by playing semantical games?

 

[JoelT1]

The British coined the word “palestinian” originally for Jews in the British Mandate temporarily named British palestine. Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews and ancient Israel.

It doesn't matter one tiny bit where the name came from. Coyote is right. The Arab Palestinians, regardless of their origins, exist now. They are a real people and they have every right to be there. Same as the Jewish people.

We can't support the rights of one people, while denying the rights of the other. THAT works both ways.

“Palestine” originated as a Roman name for ancient Israel And “palestinian” originated as a British name for Jews

Palestine & palestinian are made-up Western terms

 

[JoelT1]

Jews were originally called palestinians, by the British. Made-up word

No. Not made up.

A descriptor of very real people that live there. Real people. Just like the Jews are. Your persistent effort to diminish and demean them is not unlike that of the antisemites who do the same to the Jews.

The British coined the word “palestinian” originally for Jews in the British Mandate temporarily named British palestine. Palestine originated as a Roman name imposed on Jews and ancient Israel.

Coined or not, Palestinians are a people in today's world. Why is it so important to diminish them?

“Palestinian” coined by the British for Jews. There’s no p in Arabic

Why do you feel the need to diminish Palestinians by playing semantical games?

Arabs laugh: Palestinians never existed

 

[Shusha]

“Palestine” originated as a Roman name for ancient Israel And “palestinian” originated as a British name for Jews

Palestine & palestinian are made-up Western terms

Pick another name for the people we are talking about then. I don't care what silly name you choose, or how many drive-bys you do on different threads with your comments about the name. Its irrelevant.

 

[JoelT1]

“Palestine” originated as a Roman name for ancient Israel And “palestinian” originated as a British name for Jews

Palestine & palestinian are made-up Western terms

Pick another name for the people we are talking about then. I don't care what silly name you choose, or how many drive-bys you do on different threads with your comments about the name. Its irrelevant.

They’re simply Arabs

 

[Shusha]

“Palestine” originated as a Roman name for ancient Israel And “palestinian” originated as a British name for Jews

Palestine & palestinian are made-up Western terms

Pick another name for the people we are talking about then. I don't care what silly name you choose, or how many drive-bys you do on different threads with your comments about the name. Its irrelevant.

They’re simply Arabs

Well, that is rather broad. But let's call them Arabs, then. Do you think these particular Arabs have rights to self-determination and sovereignty and to be able to control their own destiny?

 

[JoelT1]

“Palestine” originated as a Roman name for ancient Israel And “palestinian” originated as a British name for Jews

Palestine & palestinian are made-up Western terms

Pick another name for the people we are talking about then. I don't care what silly name you choose, or how many drive-bys you do on different threads with your comments about the name. Its irrelevant.

They’re simply Arabs

Well, that is rather broad. But let's call them Arabs, then. Do you think these particular Arabs have rights to self-determination and sovereignty and to be able to control their own destiny?

There are 22 Arab countries More than enough “self-determination”

 

[Coyote]

“Palestine” originated as a Roman name for ancient Israel And “palestinian” originated as a British name for Jews

Palestine & palestinian are made-up Western terms

Pick another name for the people we are talking about then. I don't care what silly name you choose, or how many drive-bys you do on different threads with your comments about the name. Its irrelevant.

They’re simply Arabs

Well, that is rather broad. But let's call them Arabs, then. Do you think these particular Arabs have rights to self-determination and sovereignty and to be able to control their own destiny?

There are 22 Arab countries More than enough “self-determination”

How many European countries are there? Does that mean one or more do not have the right of self determination?

 

[JoelT1]

“Palestine” originated as a Roman name for ancient Israel And “palestinian” originated as a British name for Jews

Palestine & palestinian are made-up Western terms

Pick another name for the people we are talking about then. I don't care what silly name you choose, or how many drive-bys you do on different threads with your comments about the name. Its irrelevant.

They’re simply Arabs

Well, that is rather broad. But let's call them Arabs, then. Do you think these particular Arabs have rights to self-determination and sovereignty and to be able to control their own destiny?

There are 22 Arab countries More than enough “self-determination”

How many European countries are there? Does that mean one or more do not have the right of self determination?

Um, Europe is comprised of different ethnicities.